For the next outage on Larch, which recovery procedure should Mara use, and which outage gate led to the delivery-mode change?
Result comparison
| Profile | Answer | Quotes source match |
|---|---|---|
| DeepSeek Flash 1017 · low | Complete | All quotes bound |
| Luna medium · retained control | Complete | All quotes bound |
The two model profiles receive the same saved prompt and context. Semantic completeness and source binding are checked separately.
The question
126 characters · complete saved input
The question
126 characters · complete saved inputFor the next outage on Larch, which recovery procedure should Mara use, and which outage gate led to the delivery-mode change?
Outputs and evidence
DeepSeek Flash 1017 · low
Complete answer · quotes bound
DeepSeek Flash 1017 · low
Complete answer · quotes boundReview
Manual review against the frozen question, supplied originals, and time cutoff: requested facts, subject, approved-versus-tested status, and owner uncertainty are correct.
Saved output
Complete saved output · 486 characters
For Larch’s next outage, Mara should use REPLAY-0-632: the August 22 review instructs use of the recovery procedure validated on August 8, and the August 8 record shows REPLAY-0-632 was tested and restored the missing updates. The delivery-mode change was caused by the GATE-0-519 outages; on August 15 Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286, and the August 22 review kept that delivery choice. The August 8 meeting itself did not approve a delivery-mode change.
Returned citations · 6
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:14For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8.
ragflow:document:cee08b5026d842b99343b723cd632d4a:chunk:695228c0e924112aThe team tested REPLAY-0-632, which restored the missing updates.
ragflow:document:cee08b5026d842b99343b723cd632d4a:chunk:695228c0e924112aNo change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:11Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:11The cause was the GATE-0-519 outages recorded on August 8
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:14Keep the August 15 delivery choice.
Exact evidence supplied to the reader · 11 entries
ragflow:document:cee08b5026d842b99343b723cd632d4a:chunk:695228c0e924112a2026-08-08. Mara reported that BATCH-0-741 lost updates during GATE-0-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-0-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting.
ragflow:document:94e70fdbaa2744e188d47078c65371eb:chunk:3699c4c2ca3ec6572026-08-08. Ivo reported that BATCH-1-741 lost updates during GATE-1-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-1-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting.
ragflow:document:1b443da3a73f43e7afe42cd3d8d3142d:chunk:009b12b0d27c81992026-08-01. Mara started project Larch. They chose BATCH-0-741 for batch delivery. The initial retry policy was RETRY-0-108.
ragflow:document:96a9bf446d8b48ada33eb033c4c8b9f1:chunk:564ca4cb2e88ef8e2026-08-01. Ivo started project Cobalt. They chose BATCH-1-741 for batch delivery. The initial retry policy was RETRY-1-108.
ragflow:document:a9805b71009a4735b572000fb490b80b:chunk:2c0e7dd0a7264518Kestrel-0 signed return policy. Ordinary goods have a 7-day return window. The complete exception list consists of two clauses: custom-made goods use exception CUSTOM-0-7c2; quality defects use exception DEFECT-0-9b4 and are exempt from the 7-day limit. Both exception identifiers must be retained when listing all exceptions. The old informal draft listed only DRAFT-0-2d1 and has no authority.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:23User Input: 2026-08-22. Ivo reviewed Cobalt. Keep the August 15 delivery choice. For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8. The retry policy is now RETRY-1-907, superseding RETRY-1-108. No budget owner has been appointed. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:20User Input: 2026-08-15. Ivo approved switching Cobalt from BATCH-1-741 to STREAM-1-286. This supersedes the August 1 delivery decision. The cause was the GATE-1-519 outages recorded on August 8; keep the successful recovery procedure from that incident. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:14User Input: 2026-08-22. Mara reviewed Larch. Keep the August 15 delivery choice. For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8. The retry policy is now RETRY-0-907, superseding RETRY-0-108. No budget owner has been appointed. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:16The delivery choice made on August 15, 2026, is to remain in force.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:11User Input: 2026-08-15. Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286. This supersedes the August 1 delivery decision. The cause was the GATE-0-519 outages recorded on August 8; keep the successful recovery procedure from that incident. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:9User Input: 2026-08-08. Ivo reported that BATCH-1-741 lost updates during GATE-1-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-1-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting. Agent Response: Recorded.
Original files · 2 source records
- post-memory-0-1.json
File identity
- SHA-256
bc5e601af5ddb663530c0a32ea6ad2beb74eb4e2abf3e0895c39992e8ce6adc6- Size
- 4,497 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
- reader-review.json
File identity
- SHA-256
bec5b455025c835abba4dc30c58dd1e78543879058205df3d092c0f416110c7a- Size
- 3,748 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
Luna medium · retained control
Complete answer · quotes bound
Luna medium · retained control
Complete answer · quotes boundReview
Retained Luna response from the RAGFlow nightly context. No new retrieval or control call.
Saved output
Complete saved output · 263 characters
For Larch’s next outage, Mara should use REPLAY-0-632, the procedure tested on August 8 that restored the missing updates. The delivery-mode change was attributed to GATE-0-519 outages: on August 15, Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286.
Returned citations · 3
ragflow:document:cee08b5026d842b99343b723cd632d4a:chunk:695228c0e924112aThe team tested REPLAY-0-632, which restored the missing updates.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:14For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:11Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286. This supersedes the August 1 delivery decision. The cause was the GATE-0-519 outages recorded on August 8
Exact evidence supplied to the reader · 11 entries
ragflow:document:cee08b5026d842b99343b723cd632d4a:chunk:695228c0e924112a2026-08-08. Mara reported that BATCH-0-741 lost updates during GATE-0-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-0-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting.
ragflow:document:94e70fdbaa2744e188d47078c65371eb:chunk:3699c4c2ca3ec6572026-08-08. Ivo reported that BATCH-1-741 lost updates during GATE-1-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-1-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting.
ragflow:document:1b443da3a73f43e7afe42cd3d8d3142d:chunk:009b12b0d27c81992026-08-01. Mara started project Larch. They chose BATCH-0-741 for batch delivery. The initial retry policy was RETRY-0-108.
ragflow:document:96a9bf446d8b48ada33eb033c4c8b9f1:chunk:564ca4cb2e88ef8e2026-08-01. Ivo started project Cobalt. They chose BATCH-1-741 for batch delivery. The initial retry policy was RETRY-1-108.
ragflow:document:a9805b71009a4735b572000fb490b80b:chunk:2c0e7dd0a7264518Kestrel-0 signed return policy. Ordinary goods have a 7-day return window. The complete exception list consists of two clauses: custom-made goods use exception CUSTOM-0-7c2; quality defects use exception DEFECT-0-9b4 and are exempt from the 7-day limit. Both exception identifiers must be retained when listing all exceptions. The old informal draft listed only DRAFT-0-2d1 and has no authority.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:23User Input: 2026-08-22. Ivo reviewed Cobalt. Keep the August 15 delivery choice. For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8. The retry policy is now RETRY-1-907, superseding RETRY-1-108. No budget owner has been appointed. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:20User Input: 2026-08-15. Ivo approved switching Cobalt from BATCH-1-741 to STREAM-1-286. This supersedes the August 1 delivery decision. The cause was the GATE-1-519 outages recorded on August 8; keep the successful recovery procedure from that incident. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:14User Input: 2026-08-22. Mara reviewed Larch. Keep the August 15 delivery choice. For the next outage, use the recovery procedure validated on August 8. The retry policy is now RETRY-0-907, superseding RETRY-0-108. No budget owner has been appointed. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:16The delivery choice made on August 15, 2026, is to remain in force.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:11User Input: 2026-08-15. Mara approved switching Larch from BATCH-0-741 to STREAM-0-286. This supersedes the August 1 delivery decision. The cause was the GATE-0-519 outages recorded on August 8; keep the successful recovery procedure from that incident. Agent Response: Recorded.
ragflow:memory:e84293c0415341ab8c66a5e1e2b20dc6:9User Input: 2026-08-08. Ivo reported that BATCH-1-741 lost updates during GATE-1-519 outages. The team tested REPLAY-1-632, which restored the missing updates. No change of delivery mode was approved at this meeting. Agent Response: Recorded.
Original files · 2 source records
- cases.json
File identity
- SHA-256
ff4e1381c4023e5809f8355f2a088ae1a56e82c53d2b675b532f60879b00d2db- Size
- 241,477 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
- ragflow-formal-post-memory-0-1.json
File identity
- SHA-256
a71c408e48db3419a99f29f3440a5b648ba140fd46948016e0ad99b66917ff66- Size
- 2,340 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
Protocol and expected facts
Original files, case ID, and interpretation limits
Protocol and expected facts
Original files, case ID, and interpretation limitsCase ID: post-memory-0-1
- cases.json
File identity
- SHA-256
ff4e1381c4023e5809f8355f2a088ae1a56e82c53d2b675b532f60879b00d2db- Size
- 241,477 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
- oracle.json
File identity
- SHA-256
8ac3caf4055989d319ef143eb1fad280d3372c6c85113bbd639498fdc7871644- Size
- 2,788 bytes
- Source
- Preserved local report
A matching quote establishes a literal binding. Semantic support and subject correctness require separate review. Historical outputs remain unchanged.